After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.
Trailer
Cast
Galadriel Stineman
Cheryl Cooper
Denise Gossett
Naomi Miller
Kevin Joy
Levi Miller
Riley Beeson
Esther Miller - Young Naomi Miller
Ryan O'Quinn
Seth Miller
Lance E. Nichols
Chief Twitchell
Lance E. Nichols
Officer Twitchell
Lauren Paulis
Elizabeth Miller
CF
Christophe Farrell
Caleb Miller
Candace Kirkpatrick
Aunt Mitzi
NA
Nick Andrisin
Officer Nick
Kristen Grace Gonzalez
Officer Ortega
Amelia Still
Lydia
Andy S. Allen
Johnson
Andi Anderson
Kathy
Charlie Niccolini
Thomas Troyer
Cat Skugor
Renee Police Dispatch
RL
Rebecca Lam
Podcaster
Melissa Ordway
Lacey
You Might Also Like
Mystery★ 9.5
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
Crime★ 5.0
Fatal Seduction
Drama★ 5.8
Ambitions
Drama★ 8.3
Billions
Drama★ 7.6
Dying for Sex
Crime★ 8.0
The Capture
Crime★ 7.1
Absentia
Adventure★ 7.9
Da Vinci's Demons
Crime★ 6.1
Slay
Crime★ 6.4
The Madness
Documentary★ 8.0
The Keepers
Adventure★ 6.0
Cursed
Action★ 7.3
Last Resort
Adventure★ 5.3
Another Life
Drama★ 7.4
Frequency
Crime★ 8.0
The Better Woman
Comedy★ 6.5
PORN: A Series
Drama★ 6.5
War of the Worlds
Drama★ 5.9
The Rig
Crime★ 8.0
The King of Pigs
Drama★ 8.0
Travelers
Crime★ 5.5
Hunters
Game-Show★ 6.5
Temptation Island
Drama★ 7.6
The Devil's Hour
Comments
2 Comments
Henok wendmuApr 23, 2026
U
AnonymousApr 23, 2026